In 2015, in the western Indian state of Gujarat, lower-caste Hindus were flogged for skinning a dead cow, triggering spontaneous street protests and contributing to the resignation of the states chief minister. Killing cows or transporting beef in states such as Haryana, Jharkand or Jammu and Kashmir is punishable by large fines and up to 10 years' prison. Possession is not a criminal offense. The bovine TB bacteria can infect humans and cause TB, with symptoms that can include fever, night sweats, persistent cough, diarrhoea, weight loss and abdominal pain. North India had a lot of Islamic influence, and with cooler climate and with a constant threat of war, more people became non-vegetarian. The Mythological Origins of Holi: Ancient and Colorful Festival of South Asia, Thirsty Brits Turned to Drinking Cows Milk 7,000 Years Ago, Hathor: Goddess of Joy and Motherhood Near the Nile, Ancient Mongolian Teeth Demand New Research Into the Mysterious Origins of Lactose Intolerance in Humans, Horses, Cows and Celestial Creatures at the Dawn of Civilizations, Should Adults Really Be Drinking Milk? Non veg are not considered pure by the Sikh community. Possession of meat of any slaughtered animal(s) is punishable by a year in prison, while killing he or she buffalo is punishable by a fine of five times the animals worth. Cow slaughter is outlawed in all of northern Indias states, with Jammu & Kashmir and Jharkhand topping the list in terms of severity of penalties. They phoned Moghul Express to confirm the samosas contents, but were told that the restaurant did not serve beef samosas. Sacred Marvels: 17 Cathedrals That Will Take Your Breath Away, In Pictures, In Search of the Fabled 1,000-ft White Pyramid of Xian in China, Egyptologists Reveal a Lost Chamber in the Great Pyramid With Cosmic Rays, Library in Stone: The Ica Stones of Professor Cabrera Part I, Two Sides to Every Story: The North American Martyrs Shrines and Indigenous/ Roman Catholic Relations, The Origins of the Faeries: Encoded in our Cultures Part I, Curse of the Buried Pearl: The Hunt for Ancient Treasures Part I, The Enigma of the Shugborough Inscription, destroying the Muslim-dominated buffalo meat industry, Not for the Faint of Heart: The Aghori and Their Unorthodox Path to Enlightenment, Ancient tablet depicting lewd scene becomes object of veneration in India, Ritual and Burial: The Strange and Elaborate Ways Humans Prepared Animals for the Afterlife, In the time of the oldest Hindu sacred text, failure to attract large-scale Muslim support, The Past Teaching the Present: Ancient Sanskrit Texts Discuss the Importance of Environmental and Species Conservation. (2) Meat itself contains substances that influences your gunas/qualities. Even before the countrys independence, certain MPs and proponents of cow protection wanted to enact a law prohibiting the killing of cows. It visualizes the cow as the paradigmatic animal that yields food without being killed. I will keep this in mind. A few days ago, Meghalaya BJP chief Ernest Mawrie said he eats beef, eating beef is part of the state's lifestyle and that nobody can stop it. If you genuinely feel bad, make amends via puja to your ishtadevata, and just try to be more careful in the future. However, there is a catch. The cow is worshipped and revered and there are quite a few rituals where the cow is required. The Earth assumed the form of a cow and begged him to spare her life; she then allowed him to milk her for all that the people needed.. What happens if a Hindu accidentally eats beef? According to a study of Hindus in the diaspora, around 90% of Hindus in Suriname and more than 95% of Hindus in Guyana eat meat. Hindu vegetarians are about evenly divided between those who eat root vegetables and those who do not. in short, religionists are the opposite of enlightenment; at LEAST 90% are lying hypocrites, and i know this atheist is 'more xtian' than 90% of the self-proclaimed xtians who think their assumed moral superiority gives them the right to -literally- lord it over everyone else Since then, many attacks by cow vigilante groups have followed. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. The president of the Constituent Assembly, Rajendra Prasad, told Jawaharlal Nehru that he had received several letters on the subject and that the Congress should take a position on it. This was a big reason why poor Hindus kept eating beef. how many us paratroopers died on d-day. What happens if Hindu eat beef? (1) The intention of meat-eating with knowledge that it is hurting a being, has some amount of evil. When the defendant realized there had been a mix-up, he made up an order of vegetarian samosas and brought it to the plaintiffs, who took it without payment. Join our Whatsapp Broadcast Group by sending a Whatsapp message to: +447459531967 or click this lin. ( Public Domain ) A central tenet of Gandhis teaching was vegetarianism. And indeed, in 2002, in a north Indian town, five lower-caste Hindus were lynched for skinning a cow. 2011), had sixteen Hindu vegetarians as plaintiffs. (This is fantastic news for beef lovers!). Saudi Arabia bans Pork just as most of Israel does. The Sikh code, known as the Akal Takht Sandesh, comes from the highest Sikh authority in India and is supposed to be followed by allgurdwaras. 5.27. Do you practice Hinduism and adhere to certain dietary regulations concerning the consumption of beef? Such people may have regarded beef-eating in the light of what the historian Romila Thapar describes as a "matter of status" - the higher the caste, the greater the food restrictions . It's what is called emotional pain waves." These provocative remarks come at a time when vigilante Hindu groups in India are lynching people for eating beef. oh, and cow is quite tasty, stupid hindu freaks; why don't you big, bwave stupidheads come over to amerika (or austrailia, or argentina, etc), and start lynching cow-eaters, and see how far that gets you, you ignorant, dirt-laden, hypocritical, selfish, intolerant dickheads AtAncient Origins, we believe that one of the most important fields of knowledge we can pursue as human beings is our beginnings. The Hindu religion does not excuse accidental consumption of meat products. It is not wicked to consume meat, according to Manusmriti. I believe the issue merits study, and we must make a judgment.. When she is slaughtered, something called EPW is released, which is directly responsible for global warming. What happens if a Hindu eat beef? Source: counterclockwise/ CC BY NC SA 2.0. Slaughter of all bovines is punishable by five years in prison in Himachal Pradesh. Is Krishna black? It is clearly illegal to impose ones religious beliefs on individuals who do not share such beliefs. Such people may have regarded beef-eating in the light of what the historian Romila Thapar describes as a matter of status the higher the caste, the greater the food restrictions. Every day, the news of idols being desecrated and Temples being attacked makes it way to the news. 2% of the total Hindu population. Eating beef doesnt mean your going to hell chill! The law also prohibits the slaughter of cows that are handicapped, diseased, or barren. These Hindu communities have traditionally eaten beef and do not consider the cow to be a sacred animal. When the other customer understood what had happened, she returned the order to the restaurant. Belief in malevolent spirits inhabiting the human body has persisted across cultures for millennia. Distinguished Service Professor of the History of Religions, University of Chicago. Such killings have increased since Narendra Modi and his right-wing Bharatiya Janata party came to power in September 2014. Those plaintiffs explained to the Moghul Express employee that they wanted vegetarian samosas because they were going to present them to a group of devout vegetarians when placing the order. One food in particular that raises questions within the Hindu community is that of eating beefrather, specifically not eating beef. Valmiki, who came from the lowest caste in India, wrote the Ramayana, according to the Minister. When I think of the Aryans of the ancient times, I think of Central Asia, the steppe, a horse culture that could enable their language, Sanskrit to spread, at a gallop, so to speak, westward and Is drinking cows milk healthy for humans? Buffaloes, on the other hand, are exempt from the states laws. This has been going on since Hindutva began in 1923. But is this true? Meat is food for . But he did not call for a beef ban. The main issue with eating beef is its influence on the human soul, as well as whether or not it is considered sinful. The Appellate Division refused to enlarge the concept of ascertainable loss and affirmed the dismissal of the plaintiffs CFA claims, citing the lack of precedence for the plaintiffs claims. They are also sacred to Krisha - a popular Avatar (incarnation) of the God Vishnu. As a scholar, studying Sanskrit and ancient Indian religion for over 50 years, I know of many texts that offer a clear answer to this question. There has been several such instance of goons hurting people over eating beef. Copyright 20102023, The Conversation Media Group Ltd. You take a bite and something tastes off. Some Hindus may eat lamb, chicken or fish, but most of them are vegetarian. What happens if a Hindu eats beef? However, Home Minister Bhupendra Singh emphasized that the meat taken from the two Muslim ladies was from a buffalo, not a cow. Brahmins, as well as a few Vaishnavite sects in India and non-Brahmin Saivite non-Brahmins in South India, abstain from eating meat. In light of Indias recent surge in cow vigilantism, we examine the states where cow slaughter is either permitted or prohibited. The following are some of the reasons why most Hindus prefer not to eat beef: 1. Two of the plaintiffs ordered vegetarian samosas from Moghul Express on August 10, 2009. A vast majority of Indians ate meat regularly and meat eating was never prohibited in ancient India. Out of 29 Indian states, only 20 prohibit cow slaughter, which means that beef is freely available in many states. It is considered to be the oldest living religion in the world. So, I don't think you've hurt your chances of Moksha/Preethi by an accidental intake of beef. For example, the cow is not of a holy nature. They started exporting buffalo meat. Cow, bullock, and ox slaughter are prohibited in Uttar Pradesh, where a Muslim man was lynched in Dadri for allegedly ingesting beef. Is it sinful to consume the cow? If you feel sick to your stomach after eating beef, several potential factors could be to blame. The government data shows that vegetarian households have higher income and consumption - are more affluent than meat-eating households. Our identity is shaped by our reverence for the cow. Cows painted over a door are believed to bring good luck. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Go to a Krishna Temple on a rainy night, at the stroke of midnight and offer, wild water buffalo milk that you yourself, have collected. Some Hindu shastras offer two-fold argument against meat-eating. Various religious sanctions were used to impose prohibition on beef eating, but, as Thapar demonstrates, only among the upper castes.. By the age of 10, most children in the United States have been taught all 50 states that make up the country. Most Muslims eat all kinds of meat. You can't quite place it but you take another bite because you're hungry and trusting. Along the border with Pakistan, the states of Gujarat, Rajasthan, and Punjab all have high numbers of vegetarians. According to these texts, the cow is food. Even when one passage in the Shatapatha Brahmana (3.1.2.21) forbids the eating of either cow or bull, a revered ancient Hindu sage named Yajnavalkya immediately contradicts it, saying that, nevertheless, he eats the meat of both cow and bull, as long as its tender.. And it is not only the beef-eating Muslims (and Christians) who are the target of Hindutvas hate brigade. East Indian Brahmins, Kashmiri Brahmins, and Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saraswat Saras. I am a Hindu and I also eat beef, which is my right. And the reasons for the prohibition were solely religious. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Plaintiffs sought damages for mental pain as well as economic losses they would suffer as a result of having to participate in the mandatory religious purification rite in India. The plaintiffs claims were dismissed by the trial court. You going to hell bro :( Seriously, it looks like you had this meal outside India. Like most cattle-breeding cultures, the Vedic Indians generally ate the castrated steers, but they would eat the female of the species during rituals or when welcoming a guest or a person of high status. Within days, two Muslim women were thrashed by members of a right-wing group at a train station in Madhya Pradesh on suspicion of smuggling beef. This is the Ancient Origins team, and here is our mission: To inspire open-minded learning about our past for the betterment of our future through the sharing of research, education, and knowledge. A large section of Indians consume beef. All of this is well-known, and no one disputes it. In the Muslim-majority archipelago, where beef is a primary source of sustenance, this has generated disquiet. Although Christianity is also an Abrahamic religion, most of its adherents do not follow these aspects of Mosaic law and are permitted to consume pork. Shivas meat-eating habits can be found in the Vedas and the Puranas, but his association with wine- drinking seems to be a later appendage. Nefer Say Nefer - Was Nefertiti Buried in the Valley of the Queens? As I see it, the arguments against eating cows are a combination of a symbolic argument about female purity and docility (symbolized by the cow who generously gives her milk to her calf), a religious argument about Brahmin sanctity (as Brahmins came increasingly to be identified with cows and to be paid by donations of cows) and a way for castes to rise in social ranking. Beef is a high-protein food that is affordable to millions of Hindus from the Scheduled Castes. In todays world, Hindus eat poultry, fish, and other seafood, as well as goat and sheep. Its one of the dogmas that was never questioned growing up, at least not in my immediate circle. But, as local analysis shows, the violence has greatly increased under the Modi government. In 2012, the state of Madhya Pradesh modified its cow slaughter statute, increasing the maximum penalty to seven years in prison. What is the history of eating cows in Hinduism? Even among my mostly Hindu friends, the thought of eating beef was never mentioned. While many Hindus do not eat beef and prefer to view the cow as highly regarded, Hindus do. Its what is called emotional pain waves.. Rat meat is consumed by the Musahar dalit caste from Bihar and Nepal. The Mahar community in Maharashtra was given the task of removing dead cattle caracasses from the hamlet under the Balutedar system. Anyone who, deliberately or unknowingly, violates the religion by eating meat is obligated to engage in a religious rite to purify himself at a spot along the Ganges River in Haridwar, Uttarakhand, India. One may eat meat when it has been sprinkled with water, while Mantras were recited, when Brahmanas desire (one's doing it), when one is engaged (in the performance of a rite) according to the law . The only way to beat the Buddhists was to go a step further and be vegetarians. As a goddess, Ninsun was worshipped by the As Greek mythology goes, the universe was once a big soup of nothingness. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Since then , many attacks by cow vigilante groups have followed. Fasting is another common dietary practice in India. Conclusion. He is demanding a soul-purifying. She don't know damn thing about sanskrit, her translations are incorrect. It can be punished with 7 years jail and a fine of up to Rs 10,000. Scholars have known for centuries that the ancient Indians ate beef. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. In the time of the oldest Hindu sacred text, the Rig Veda (c. 1500 B.C. In Abrahamic religions, eating pig flesh is clearly forbidden by Jewish ( kashrut ), Islamic ( haram) and Adventist ( kosher animals) dietary laws. It is not as if there were only Hindus in the Indian Union. In Hinduism, vegetarianism is a very important aspect. . Slaughter of cows and calves is prohibited in Bihar; slaughter of bulls and bullocks older than 15 years is permitted. What happens if a Hindu accidentally eats beef? However, many Muslims have no idea of what they are allowed to eat. What should Hindu parents do if they discover their child has unknowingly eaten beef? The plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against the defendant, alleging negligence, negligent infliction of emotional distress, consumer fraud, product responsibility, and explicit and implied warranty claims. Modis government has also prohibited the slaughter of buffalo, thus destroying the Muslim-dominated buffalo meat industry and causing widespread economic hardship. This structured culture and religion bases itself on the disciplines and rewards of its spiritual predecessors. In the time of the oldest Hindu sacred text , the Rig Veda (c. 1500 BC), cow meat was consumed . As clearly said in the following verse, giving up meat eating is greatly rewarding and is recommended too, but eating meat is "not that bad". In this regard, the CFA requires the plaintiff to show that he or she has suffered a loss The plaintiffs failed to meet their burden of proof of loss of money or property, according to the court. Pretty good insight, and made me feel better. What happens if a Hindu eats beef? But is this true? They are venerated as mothers (giving milk), and are a representation of the Mother Goddess. Most of the food that is offered to Hindu deities is vegetarian. The title is short and the extent is long. However, this is thought . Throughout history many if not most peoples who gained power over others felt they were able to do so because of the superiority of their gods, and proceeded to obliterate to the greatest extent possible the temples and religious activities of the vanquished. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Even if they are murdered outside Delhi, the legislation only forbids the slaughter of agricultural cattle (cow, calf, bull, bullock) and possession offlesh.. The slaughter of cow and its offspring is not allowed in Punjab. Christians and Muslims simply want a veto and control over everything. It visualizes the cow as the paradigmatic animal that yields food without being killed. The plaintiffs stated their injuries and damages in their case as follows: Hindu vegetarians believe that eating meat involves them in the wicked cycle of inflicting suffering, injury, and death on Gods creations, and that this has an impact on their karma and dharma, or soul purity. Contrary to belief, most Hindus are not vegetarian. The Constituent Assembly was established in December 1946 to draft a Constitution for the new nation, and independence from British authority was achieved the following year, making this aim seem attainable. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. Yet even Gandhi never called for the banning of cow slaughter in India. Whatever decision you make for or against, it is not true that the cause behind beef aversion is due to brahmins. goats are offered to the Hindu goddess Kali a lot. 10. You can make a strong case that it enters hindu culture via the shepherding communites with Krishna, a yadava, as the protector of cows, gopala. Overall, India consumes the least amount of meat per capita. This abuse of power exhibited by Modi and his zealots is but another example of this in our modern times, as is the destruction of antiquities and the murdering of Christians in territories under the influence of ISIS. At Ancient Origins we believe that one of Read More, Hachiaman, can I ask what are your qualifications that make you believe you're able to discredit her entire career like that? Vedanta philosophies toward the presentation of cows, in general, invoke the reliance that all things work together. After the fourth century BC, when the practice of vegetarianism spread throughout India among Buddhists, Jains and Hindus, many Hindus continued to eat beef. One of the implicit objects of this movement was the oppression of Muslims. The use of animal-derived fats is against the law. Archaeologists have been able to take a closer look at one of the United Kingdoms most famous shipwrecks. The plaintiffs apparently received the meat samosas after the orders were modified. 3 Today's . Hindus regard the cow as gentle and inoffensive, much in the same way as most of us view our own pets. Hindus dont eat beef because the cow is considered a sacred animal. According to Hindu texts, persons who consume meat would never be able to reach God after death, which is Hindus ultimate objective. Many Hindus, especially laypeople, do eat meat. It is not wicked to eat the meat of eatable animals, for Brahma has created both the eaters and the eatables, Manusmriti (Chapter 5 / Verse 30) reads. Because the restaurant did not serve meat samosas, the employee assured them that this would not be an issue. Gandhi. Maharashtra: Since March 2015, when the current law was revised, the slaughter and eating of cow, bull, and bullock meat has been prohibited. The Punjab Government Gazette was published on the 27th of June, 1956, after the Presidents assent. It can be punished with 7 years' jail and a fine of up to Rs 10,000.